MARCH 18 2004 DOC 1104041500000J IEEE P80211 WIRELESS LANS

CABINET 13TH MARCH 2012 MEETING COMMENCED 1000AM ADJOURNED
  PUESTA EN MARCHA DE PROGRAMA PARA IMPULSAR
PUESTA EN MARCHA PUESTA EN MARCHA LA REFORMA

UNOFFICIAL FUNDS MANUAL OF GUIDANCE MARCH
3 LAST UPDATED 29 MARCH 2007 EU
9 CONFORMED COPY MARCH 29 2010 HIS EXCELLENCY

doc.: 11-04-0415-00-000j

March 18, 2004 doc.: 11-04-0415-00-000j

IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs

TGj AM Meeting Minutes

Date: March 18, 2004

Author: Robert Soranno
JHU/APL
Laurel, MD

Phone: 443-778-8947
Fax: 443-778-5928
e-Mail: [email protected]

Minutes


The meeting called to order at 8:05 AM by Sheung Li, Chairman. Sheung indicated that a number of people in the group are not attending the meetings and voting. Consequently, an inadequate number of people are voting on issues. A discussion followed amongst the members regarding dropping individuals from the group who have not attended the meeting for a long period of time.


A document was developed by the standard’s editor and loaded into the task group area that comprises all ballot comments to the latest version of the draft. The group addressed up to Comment 34 yesterday. The comments specify the areas affected and contain the information that should be added or replaced. A number of comments address using other 802.11 documents. In many cases, because this document addresses operations in Japan, they are not applicable and new requirements must be specified.


The ballot comment document is entered as 11-04-0042-000j-tgj-comment-resolution-1b64. The editor addressed the comments in order. The chairman recorded the group’s resolution to the comments in the appropriate column of the table.


Specific comments addressed in this meeting are as follows:















Issue A’s resolution requires to change the coverage class table to eliminate the shortcut and show the sum of the numbers needed to arrive at the results.


Timing is assumed to be one-way in the base standard, but two-way must be considered in the “j” document. It is felt that the equation is wrong in the base standard, and must be fixed. Either we must get the base fixed, or modify the equation by using a two-way propagation time in “j”. The final decision was to change the aSlotTime for Clause 17 PHY, range <<300 meters in Table 22 from 13 usec to 16 usec. In that manner the base document equations do not have to be changed. Clause 17 PHY will be moved from the Comments Column to the “aSlotTime” Columns in Table 22. This change responds to Comment #52 from Andrew Myles. Clause J.17.3.8.6 will also be fixed accordingly.


A resolution was made that the editor resolve Issue A by the 1:30 meeting today.


Issue B requested that mechanisms be inserted in the base standard to bind regulations to Japan. Issue B applies to Comments 8, 9, 41 and 42 amongst others. However, to respond to these comments, we will make the starting frequency an integer, by indicating that the MIB value is in units of 500KHz. Additional clarification will be inserted in the document. Corrections need to be made in 802.11d, which has been incorporated into the new base document.


A country element is being included in .11j in Section 9.9. A regulatory annex will be constructed that must be referenced in Section 9.9 to point to tables by countries.


Break taken @ 10:00 AM.


The meeting resumed @ 10:30 AM with the editor, Peter Ecclesine again leading the addressing of ballot comments. Comment #3 was the first to be addressed. As before, all comment resolution was recorded in the appropriate column of the file for presentation at the plenary meeting.


Comments #19 –21 were next addressed. They noted a difference in the way in which countries are handled in 802.11e vs. j.


The comment resolution document as handled by the chairman was entered on the server as document –411 so that everyone could review comment resolution and approve or disapprove everything added so far.


The editor took a deadline to have all comments integrated into the document by the end of the month.


All “Issue A” comments were addressed and resolved.


For Comment # 75, a vote of 5 accept – 1 reject – 4 abstain vote was taken to accept the comment.


All comments were resolved. Sheung uploaded the new comment resolution document as “0411/r1”.


A lunch recess was taken @ 12:20.



The meeting resumed at 1:35 PM in the same fashion with Sheung Li presenting and recording the comments to the standard draft while the editor addressed them with recommendations.


To address comments 19 – 21, which were put off in the morning until further research could be conducted by the editor, it was recommended that modifications be added to section 9.9.1 to describe carrier sensing in relation to fragmentation. As there were no other changes to add to the document, the chairman took a motion and a vote to submit the final version of the comment resolution document as “0411/r2”. A vote was taken with a result of 7 for – 0 against and 0 abstain.


A motion was made to have the editor revise the draft standard to incorporate all approved changes as documented in the 0411/r2 document. The motion was seconded, balloted on, and accepted with a vote of 6 for – 0 against – 0 abstain.


A motion was made to hold a 16 day air ballot with follow-on. The motion was seconded, and balloted with a vote of 6 for – 0 against – 0 abstain.


A motion to request a Procedure 10 issuance of a sponsor ballot subsequent to the acceptance of a recirculation ballot was made. It was seconded. A vote of 7 for –0 against –0 abstain approved it.


A motion was made to hold an adhoc and interim meetings as well as teleconferences as necessary to review the draft before the May IEEE 802 meeting. The motion was seconded. A vote was taken receiving 7 for – 0 against- 0 abstain.


At 1:50PM a motion was made by the chairman to adjourn the TGj meeting for both today and the remainder of the March IEEE meeting. The motion was seconded and unanimously approved by the members.



Submission page 3 Robert Soranno, JHU/APL


GENEALOGY PATHFINDER MARCH 2012 PLACES TO START
0 MEMORANDUM DATE MARCH 8 2006 SUBJECT ACTION
0 N097516 MARCH 25 2010 CLA290OTRRNCN4405 CATEGORY CLASSIFICATION TARIFF


Tags: 1104041500000j, march, p80211, wireless